|
Printer
Friendly Page
Global
Medicine
by Eve Jacobs
Preventing and fighting the twin scourges of HIV and
TB, and giving kids with facial anomalies a chance at a normal
life, take UMDNJ professionals to locales as far away as Botswana,
Guyana, Thailand, South Africa, Uganda, China, Brazil and
Ecuador.
It’s just under 3,000 miles as the crow flies from
Newark, New Jersey to Guayaquil, Ecuador, but human travel
is rarely so direct. When the oral and maxillofacial surgery
team lands at Simon Bolivar International Airport on Sunday
evening, after an exhausting day of travel including a stopover
in Houston to pick up additional staff, they look forward
to a menu of dinner, then sleep. Come early Monday morning
all 16 travelers — four surgeons, two residents, five
anesthesiologists and five nurses — need to be sharp.
They have a tough five days ahead of them.
At 7 am, 100 mothers and their young children will be lined
up at Guayaquil’s largest children’s hospital
— Hospital Del Nino — patiently waiting to see
the doctors. Each mother is hoping her child will be among
those chosen to have their cleft lip and/or palate treated.
The team has just four days to do their magic and lives will
be transformed, or not, based upon the surgeons’ hard
decisions. First the doctors will evaluate their young patients
and document their findings. Each waiting child will be assigned
a number — 1 for a definite yes, 2 means “if time
allows,” or 3, a definite no, due to the complexity
of the surgical procedure that needs to be done or an underlying
condition that would preclude general anesthesia. The group
will try to arrange for these more complicated surgeries to
be carried out at a future time in the U.S. (Last year, they
saw a young boy missing an eye and arranged for him to come
to this country for a prosthesis.)
The team will work in three different operating rooms simultaneously,
each surgeon performing about 20 surgeries in four days, each
procedure taking about two hours. By week’s end, 60
of these children — age two months to teens —
will be visibly transformed. It’s a heavy load. They
begin operating at 1 pm on Monday, right after the evaluations
are completed, and finish that day’s work in time to
have a late dinner, sleep and start all over again at 7 am
on Tuesday. That will be their routine until Saturday, when
they do hospital rounds in the morning, then spend half a
day touring the city, picking up gifts for family members
and friends, and maybe spending a few hours at the beach or
the park where iguanas sleep by the pond — directly
across from their hotel.
Researchers
are not sure why cleft lips and palates are far more common
in Central America than other parts of the world. Genetics
and prenatal folate deficiencies are believed to play a role.
The 100 young faces lined up for the doctors’ scrutiny
are simultaneously pictures of deformity and beauty. So many
of them, each with a cleft lip or palate, or another major
facial defect. These kinds of birth defects are far more common
in Central America, according to Shahid R. Aziz, MD, DMD,
assistant professor of oral and maxillofacial surgery at UMDNJ-New
Jersey Dental School (NJDS) and one of the surgeons on this
“Healing the Children” journey. Why are these
defects so common? “We don’t really know,”
he says. “Probably it’s a combination of genetics
and a prenatal vitamin deficiency, specifically a folate deficiency.”
Inadequate intake of folate (also known as folic acid) during
pregnancy is known to sometimes result in congenital neural
tube defects, including malformations of the spine (spina
bifida), skull and brain (anencephaly). More recently, this
nutritional deficiency has been linked to other birth defects.
Where do all these children come from? Many residents of
this gritty city, and the villages and towns surrounding it,
are extraordinarily poor, explains Aziz, and paying for a
child’s complex surgery is way out of their reach. An
advertisement — that runs for a month prior to the surgeons’
arrival — alerts parents to the possibility of getting
this life-altering medical treatment for free. And truly,
the lives of entire families can be changed in just a matter
of hours.
Cleft lips, says Aziz, are chiefly a “cosmetic”
problem, but ultimately this deformity will cause the child
to be treated as an outcast. Cleft palates, on the other hand,
are generally a functional issue, he explains, producing an
open path from mouth to nose. This means that a baby will
have to struggle for nourishment, since sucking is affected,
and milk can enter the nose directly from the mouth. Both
defects can affect speech, and in older children, eating.
In the U.S., where these facial malformations are relatively
rare (1 child in 1,000), cleft lips are usually repaired at
10 weeks of age, cleft palates when the child is nine to18
months. “The surgery is so much harder when the child
is older,” says Aziz. An older child may also suffer
psychological consequences lasting long after the defect is
successfully repaired.
Each cleft presents the surgical team with a different challenge.
Cleft lips can range in severity from a slight notch in the
upper lip to a complete separation of the lip, extending to
the nose, on one side of the upper lip or both. Cleft palates
also range in seriousness, from a small opening at the back
of the palate to a complete separation of the roof of the
mouth, extending from front to back, on one side or both.
Surgical repair is more complex than for cleft lips, involving
rebuilding the palate, moving tissue from the sides of the
cleft to the center of the palate and rejoining muscle. In
both cases, the surgical team will have a very high success
rate, says Aziz. In Guayaquil, the children usually remain
in the hospital for one or two days, and are cared for by
the hospital’s nursing staff. The level of care, says
the surgeon, is very good.
The group that Aziz travels and operates with is very experienced
in this specialty. The team’s leader, Steven M. Roser,
DMD, MD, is chief of the Division of Oral and Maxillofacial
Surgery at Emory University. He was formerly at the School
of Dental and Oral Surgery at Columbia University, and has
been heading up such traveling teams to Guatemala and Colombia
for almost 10 years. Three years ago, deciding that these
sites were not safe for his volunteers, Roser decided to take
the team to Ecuador. He recruits most of the group’s
members. Aziz — who received his dental degree from
Harvard and his medical degree from Columbia — trained
under Roser and calls him his mentor. He takes one oral/maxillofacial
surgery resident from NJDS on each trip (in 2003 it was Michelle
Bergen Shapiro and in 2004 Thomas Chiodo). This year the team
will do their work in the city of Manta, located four hours
from Guayaquil on the coast.
Each volunteer pays his own travel and hotel expenses, a
cost of about $1,000, and solicits monetary donations to underwrite
other expenses. The group is often able to raise $20,000 to
$25,000, and sometimes donations of equipment and supplies,
such as suture material and antibiotics, from manufacturers.
These, along with donations of toys and clothing for the children,
are sent to the hospital about one month ahead of the team’s
travel date. An Ecuadorian medical foundation called Fundacion
El Cielo Para los Ninos de Ecuador — dedicated to the
repair of cleft lips and palates in that country — makes
arrangements with the hospital, advertises for the patients,
and arranges for the care of the children post surgery.
Surgeons
from “Heal the Children” operate for free. Children
come from surrounding villages for the life-altering surgical
procedures that their families are too poor to afford.
Aziz, who participates in about 100 facial reconstruction
surgeries annually, many as part of the maxillofacial trauma
service at UMDNJ-University Hospital, says within a year or
two, he would like to lead a group from the University, perhaps
to China, Mexico, Guatemala or Costa Rica, or even Pakistan,
if it becomes safer for Americans. “The need is definitely
there,” he says, “but we have to ensure the safety
of the volunteers.”
The surgeon goes on to explain that this humanitarian journey
does not only benefit the children; it also has a huge effect
on the lives of the medical workers. They gain valuable educational
experience – improving their skills in correcting these
congenital defects which they see only infrequently in the
U.S. — and Aziz says, “They will be reminded about
why they went into healthcare. Being a surgeon is about helping
people — making a good income is secondary. When you
participate in a humanitarian mission like this one, it has
a life-changing impact that you can never forget.”
Fighting AIDS on the frontier
In Botswana, where the numbers of lives lost to AIDS —
and those devastated by the ripple effect of those losses
— is beyond our ability to measure and comprehend, orphans
age 8, 9, 10 try to play parent to younger siblings and sometimes
to grandparents, too. The shadow of the AIDS stalker is long
and scary. With 36 percent of its adult population thought
to be HIV positive, Botswana may have the world’s highest
rate of infection. (In Francistown, a travel hub and magnet
for the young and up-and-coming of the nation, the infection
rate is put at 45 to 50 percent.) More than 20 million people
worldwide have already died of AIDS, and 42 million are estimated
to be living with the virus, 30 million of them in sub-Saharan
Africa. Experts say 68 million more people could die of the
disease by the year 2020.
Much closer to home, some of the countries lining the Caribbean
— where the natural beauty belies the dire situation
— have the highest prevalence of HIV/AIDS in the world
outside of Africa. The hardest hit are Haiti and Guyana, where
studies have shown that HIV infection may run as high as 46
percent among sex workers in Georgetown, the capital and primary
port.
Most of us read about the potential wreckage of entire countries
and cultures and are overwhelmed, not even able to envision
making a dent. But UMDNJ infectious disease experts —
many with almost two decades of experience gained fighting
HIV domestically — frequently travel into these epidemic
hot spots. They know the battle is slow and sometimes dreary,
but over the years, they have had some major successes on
the home front. Now, they forge professional and personal
relationships with other healthcare workers, and political
figures, in Botswana, Uganda, Thailand, Guyana, South Africa,
Brazil — teaching a weary, but willing, healthcare force
how to beat back this killer in their own countries. Of course,
a commitment of U.S. dollars — $15 billion by the federal
government over five years — is a critical element in
what will turn this dire situation around.
Take Mary Boland, PhD, RN, nurse, educator, researcher, HIV/AIDS
specialist. She has gained a wealth of expertise during her
14 years leading the development of programs at UMDNJ’s
Francois-Xavier Bagnoud (FXB) Center, which has as one its
major missions the prevention of mother-to-child transmission
of HIV worldwide. She was a natural to tap when the CDC geared
up for its new initiatives abroad.
Participating
in a humanitarian mission has a life-changing impact, says
Shahid R. Aziz, MD, DMD.
Georgetown, Guyana is just one of the locations where she
hopes to make serious inroads. Teaming up with Tom Denny,
MS, associate professor of pathology and laboratory medicine
at UMDNJ-New Jersey Medical School (NJMS), who has 20 years
experience in HIV/AIDS laboratory testing, and Guyana’s
Ministry of Health, they will build, equip, staff and set
in motion an HIV/AIDS reference laboratory there. It may not
sound like much, but this lab will make accurate diagnosis
possible, she explains, as well as monitoring the immune status
of the patients. Without reliable diagnostics and testing,
knowing when to start prescribing retrovirals, and when to
change the mix of drugs in the cocktail because one or more
of them have become ineffective, is purely a shot in the dark.
These life-extending therapies are just now becoming more
widely available in many developing countries, where the majority
of the HIV-infected have gotten no drug treatment at all.
The UMDNJ team will also provide clinical training for Guyana’s
health care workers, get HIV/AIDS into the curriculum at universities
that train physicians, nurses and social services personnel,
and offer mentorships with faculty in Newark. Chuka Anude,
MD, and Gisele Pemberton, MPH, have already been hired to
provide medical services and run the Georgetown lab. In Botswana,
the team will work with an existing lab, but the building
of academic, clinical and research relationships– all
aimed at saving the lives of the HIV-infected and preventing
further infection — will be much the same as in Guyana.
With so many millions infected by this virus in countries
where it may take years to adequately bolster the healthcare
infrastructure, the pressing issue is what can be done now
to make an impact. Unlike conundrums that stymie even the
most brilliant, this one has a somewhat obvious answer. Stop
vertical transmission — mother to child — and
you’ve saved a generation, at least for awhile.
“The regimen for preventing mother-to-child transmission
of HIV is much simpler than treating persons already infected
with the virus,” explains Paul Palumbo, MD, NJMS professor
of pediatrics. He also serves as Vice Chair of the Pediatric
AIDS Clinical Trials Group (PACTG), a national organization
that devises and carries out HIV/AIDS research protocols domestically
and abroad, currently in Brazil, Thailand, and South Africa.
The risk of HIV transmission from mother to newborn, which
can occur at the time of birth or while nursing, is about
40 percent. According to Palumbo, a single dose of the drug
nevirapine, administered to the mother orally during labor,
and a single dose to the infant within 72 hours of being born,
have been shown to cut transmission in half.
Because the drug is relatively effective, and cheap, “it
is a central approach for countries with limited resources,”
he says. Its down side is that “it is the type of drug
that HIV develops resistance to easily.” Since nevirapine
is frequently part of a three-drug cocktail used to treat
HIV-infected children and adults, the researchers are investigating
whether a single dose of the drug will bring about treatment
failure later on.
“For countries using nevirapine for both prevention
and treatment, getting answers to this question now is a high
priority,” Palumbo explains.
“There is a lot of research being conducted overseas
but we don’t devise a cookbook for how to do this,”
says Boland, who works closely with Palumbo conducting research
in mother-to-child transmission and drug therapies at four
sites, two in South Africa, one in Bangkok and one in ChiangMai.
“In each locale, the approach is collaborative and unique
to that place. But it’s important to use the same research
standards globally. The U.S. is a leader in that area.”
TB just won’t go away
Tuberculosis is a worldwide problem that has a very long
history. Despite a number of effective medications both for
prevention and treatment, TB just will not go away. One-third
of the world’s population, or two billion people, have
latent tuberculosis infections, and 10 percent of them will
develop active disease in their lifetimes. While aggressive
drug therapy has pummeled this infection into submission in
the U.S., it is still a massive killer abroad, particularly
in locales where HIV travels unchecked. Together, they are
a brutal adversary.
George McSherry, MD, NJMS associate professor of pediatrics,
and a tuberculosis specialist, has designed a PACTG study
that will take place at the Chris Hani Baragwanath Hospital
in Soweto, South Africa, the “twin city” of Johannesburg.
According to McSherry, there are 30,000 deliveries in that
hospital each year, and 25 to 30 percent of mothers are HIV
positive.
Because those infected with HIV are more prone to contract
tuberculosis, the study will look at how effective the drug
Isoniazid (INH) — a mainstay of TB treatment in the
U.S. — is in preventing TB and latent TB infection among
South African infants who have been exposed to HIV perinatally.
These are infants whose mothers have been tested for HIV infection,
and have been treated with nevirapine during labor. The newborns
have also been treated with one dose of the drug after birth.
At the postnatal check-up on day 3, mothers will be asked
for permission to enroll the child in the TB prevention trial.
If the mother agrees, the child will get INH or a placebo
at four months old, and will be treated for two years and
followed for an additional two years. “Of course, if
the child is suspected of actually having tuberculosis, he
will be treated for the disease immediately,” says McSherry.
The research group’s goal is to enroll 1,300 children
at two sites in South Africa over 18 to 24 months. “There
are many nuances to enrolling kids in clinical trials,”
says McSherry, who also collaborates with Boland and Palumbo
on HIV/AIDS trials. “It takes years to build trusting
relationships with healthcare providers in other countries,
and to transfer an entire system and way of thinking.”
The spread of HIV in countries where TB has grown roots “explodes
like gasoline to a match,” says Lee Reichman, MD, MPH,
professor of medicine at NJMS, whose career has been dedicated
to stamping out TB here and abroad. But because we live in
a world of global travel, “to control it anywhere, you
have to control it everywhere,” he says.
Reichman calls TB (which kills two million people each year)
and HIV (responsible for three million deaths annually) the
“diseases of mass destruction.” He points out
that other headline-grabbing infections are not even in the
same league with these two. SARS killed 813 last year, Ebola
244, West Nile 232, anthrax 5, smallpox 0 and mad cow disease
1, he says.
According to Reichman, TB is the world’s most serious
infectious threat because, unlike HIV, it is airborne, and
can be transmitted without long-term or intimate contact.
Coughing, sneezing and even speaking, if the larynx is infected,
move these germs quite efficiently from person to person.
In his book Timebomb, the Global Epidemic of Multi-Drug-Resistant
Tuberculosis, he tells the story of a young Ukrainian man
who travels from Paris to New York on a 7-hour-plane flight
in September 1998. No one was aware that he had active tuberculosis
until three days later when he sought medical treatment at
a clinic in Erie County, PA. (It was later reported that he
had been coughing during most of the flight.) The physician
diagnosed TB, and notified public health officials, who tracked
down all passengers sitting near the sick man on the plane,
as well as his close contacts in the U.S. Thirteen of these
individuals tested positive for tuberculosis infection.
As it turned out, the man’s strain of TB was resistant
to six of the nine drugs most commonly used to treat the infection.
It took 16 months of aggressive treatment with several drugs
until he was pronounced cured.
The Ukraine and other republics of the former Soviet Union
have been battling an epidemic of multi drug resistant (MDR)
TB for several years. Central to that epidemic are the prisons
in Siberia. The disease spreads through crowded cells, and
not only are the drugs inadequate, but physicians don’t
know how to use them to treat this disease. It’s a recipe
for catastrophe. Each year, some of these infected prisoners
are released and go home and spread the drug-resistant strains
to intimate and even casual contacts. Reichman says that of
those who are left untreated, or are inadequately treated,
half will die and the other half will go on to spread the
tuberculosis.
As distant as TB in Siberia or the Ukraine seems to be from
our borders, it’s really as close as one man on a plane
— or perhaps an adopted baby. That’s why Reichman
and his team have hosted Russian physicians to study at the
NJMS National TB Center in Newark, and have traveled abroad
to teach medical staff how to curb the spread of these deadly
strains. Most recently under a contract from USAID, they have
written and published a best practices guide for primary care
physicians in Russia. It will serve as a reference in their
day-to-day practices. “Multi-drug resistance is always
manmade, always the result of medical care gone awry,”
Reichman states. This joint project with the World Health
Organization is based on focus groups conducted with physicians
from the former Soviet Union. The group hopes to write best
practices guides for other locales, such as the Philippines,
struggling with the same problems.
TB in the time of AIDS and AIDS in the time of TB are beasts
like none we’ve known before. Disease has never respected
national boundaries, but now deadly germs jump continents
and oceans effortlessly, using the very modes of transportation
that our global economy depends upon. It turns out that global
medicine is not just the domain of the adventurous or the
heroic, but simply of those who understand how very tiny is
our ever shrinking world.
|